Cayo Caribe
The old-town branch of a seafood restaurant, open every day until 21:30 or 22:30. An easy choice near the walls.
- Address
- 305 Calle del Recinto Sur, Old San Juan
- How to book
- Walk in, or see its website for the menu and groups
From the sea
Fried fish in the old town, ceviche nachos by the marina and a long-running Santurce seafood room.

San Juan serves fish fried whole, in tacos, in ceviche and with rice. These three cover the old town, the marina and Calle Loíza.
All three take walk-ins. Qué Pezca'o closes at 18:00 early in the week.
Fish and shellfish cooked well, a strong rating from diners and a mention in a named guide.
The old-town branch of a seafood restaurant, open every day until 21:30 or 22:30. An easy choice near the walls.
A fish-market restaurant near the marina with ceviche nachos and fried cod tacos, per The Infatuation. It closes at 18:00 from Sunday to Wednesday.
A Puerto Rican seafood restaurant on Calle Loíza with more than 3,500 Google reviews. It is open every day, and late on Friday and Saturday.