For a long dinner

The best Italian restaurants in New York

Pasta rooms, red-sauce classics and the modern kitchens that grew out of them.

6 places · Updated October 2026 · chosen with Michelin, The New York Times, The Infatuation, Time Out and World's 50 Best · Tell us if this changed

Fresh pasta being made by hand
Fresh pasta being made by hand.Photograph Jorge Zapata / Unsplash

Italian cooking has been part of New York for well over a century, and the city still does it in every register: the old red-sauce rooms, West Village trattorias with a line at the door, and pasta kitchens in Brooklyn.

The best of them are booked weeks out at dinner; the bar seats and early tables are the way in.

What we looked for

Pasta made in the house, dishes the city talks about, and a room that suits a long evening.

  1. 01

    Lilia

    Williamsburg · Italian · $$$

    Missy Robbins's pasta house, No. 36 on The New York Times list for 2026. The sheep's milk agnolotti are the order; the bar keeps seats for walk-ins.

    Address
    567 Union Avenue
    Getting a table
    Released about 30 days ahead at 10:00; bar seats and some outdoor tables kept for walk-ins
  2. 06

    Lucali

    Carroll Gardens · Pizza · $$

    A pizza at Lucali
    A pizza at Lucali.Photograph Praneeth Thalla / Wikimedia Commons

    Mark Iacono makes only pizza and calzone in Carroll Gardens. Order a plain basil pie first, then one with hot pepper, shallot and pepperoni; cash only, bring your own wine.

    Address
    575 Henry Street, Brooklyn
    Getting a table
    No bookings; names go on the list from 16:00

More guides

Five nights in New York, planned to the hour.